Page 1 of 1

Why a fire extinguisher is a good idea...

Posted: Fri May 15, 2009 8:14 pm
by Rhod
Earlier this week I fitted a new Exrider 105AH battery into the Mazda Kitchen Unit. The battery terminals were on the opposite sides to the original, so I extended the +ve lead to let it reach. Today I used the Bongo for the first time since fitting & drove the 4 miles into work - everything seemed ok. Driving back this evening, prior to heading off to Galloway for the weekend, I was almost home when I noticed the Leisure Battery cut-out switch LED (Still Desperate modification) on the dash flickering. At the same time I got a smell of burning plastic & saw smoke in the back of the van. I hit the hazards, leapt out of the front & back in the side door, grabbing the extinguisher en route. Opening the battery compartment door on the cube, there were flames licking up from the battery leads :shock: The extinguisher did it's job. I disconnected the -ve lead & drove home - to spend the next 2 hours cleaning extinguisher powder out of the kitchen unit. They don't half make a mess, but I hate to think what would have happened if I hadn't had one [-o<

The circuit has obviously shorted out somewhere, but where & how :?:
On the Mazda Cube, the +ve & -ve battery leads are seperate only for a few inches before they are wrapped together into the loom. The -ve lead has broken about 2" beyond this point, inside the loom. The ends look almost as if they had been cut, and I doubt that the heat of the fire would have been enough to melt the copper, or that the break would look so clean. So the question is, could a break in the -ve cable which was making & breaking contact cause heat which would break down the insulation on both leads, resulting in a short across them?

Re: Why a fire extinguisher is a good idea...

Posted: Fri May 15, 2009 8:44 pm
by francophile1947
I suppose that it's possible that the flowing current could result in arcing between the gaps - that can certainly generate a load of heat that could melt the plastic insulation.

Re: Why a fire extinguisher is a good idea...

Posted: Fri May 15, 2009 8:53 pm
by Rhod
Thanks John - useful input.
I should add that lights, fridge etc were all switched off, although the monitoring system does take a small current from the battery.

When I extended the +ve lead I used a blue butt-join crimp connection because it was the only one I had handy. I intended to replace this with something beefier to be on the safe side. This doesn't appear to have been the source of the fire however & I'm fairly confident that it would handle the current loading in any case. Extending the lead did mean that I stretched the cables a little during the process, so this could have been enough to pull the broken ends of the -ve lead apart I suppose, leading to arcing.

Re: Why a fire extinguisher is a good idea...

Posted: Fri May 15, 2009 8:54 pm
by mikexgough
every vehicle should have one and when they are £6.68 at Lidl...... no excuses....

I suppose as safety devices like Triangles,Hi Viz vests (CE approved),Bulb kits, Extinguishers and First Aid Kits are treated as an optional accessory in the UK rather than a legal requirement, UK driver ignore having these valuable devices in their vehicles....

As a driver who travels Europe, I have all the above and a spare pair of specs too.....

Glad you managed to kill the fire.....

Re: Why a fire extinguisher is a good idea...

Posted: Fri May 15, 2009 10:29 pm
by northerntaff
Can't help you on the techie side of things, but damn good job you had the extinguisher...well done on averting a complete disaster =D> =D>

Re: Why a fire extinguisher is a good idea...

Posted: Fri May 15, 2009 10:50 pm
by cheffy34
Good show with the extinguisher :wink: a brake glass hammer is another good one to have :wink:


Dar

Re: Why a fire extinguisher is a good idea...

Posted: Sat May 16, 2009 12:22 am
by munroman
Hi Rhod, the extra resistance caused by the frayed/broken wires would lead to heating at the weak spot, so it could easily have melted through the insulation at this point.

As I have a factory kitchen guess what I will be checking in the morning!

Glad that you saved the situation, well done for the quick reactions!

Re: Why a fire extinguisher is a good idea...

Posted: Sat May 16, 2009 11:05 am
by mikeonb4c
Phew. I broke out in a hot sweat reading this. Well done Rhod and his extinguisher for saving the day =D>

Nothing beats soldering and heatshrink tubing when the going gets serious I reckon. Maybe solder in a new run of wiring with some extra spare length, starting from a safe, unstressed point some way back up the loom. And is a fuse right by the +ve terminal a good idea so any naughty stuff like that is prevented from getting out of hand? Maybe also one of those isolator terminals if battery not needed for a lot of the time?

Re: Why a fire extinguisher is a good idea...

Posted: Sat May 16, 2009 8:28 pm
by Rhod
Time for an update..
Just spent the day stripping out the Cube in order to fit my spare loom. In addition to the possible broken -ve lead, there was also bare wire showing at the point where the 2 battery leads join into the main loom. The loom is stressed at this point as it tries to turn in several directions & there are also a few sharp metal edges around. I'm pretty sure that the loom has been rubbing at this point & has shorted out, although the fire seems to have started further up the spur at the broken lead.

My new loom is routed very carefully, has half a roll of insulation tape reinforcing suspect points & every metal edge in the Cube sub-frame has piping protectors :!:

The original loom had butterfly nuts on the connectors, which meant a panic disconnection was easy. The new one has nuts, so I'll be fitting a quick release set as soon as I can get hold of them.

An inline fuse beside the battery, as Mike suggests is a good idea & is also on my shopping list.

I still need to extend the new loom so that the +ve lead will reach the terminal. I don;t really trust my soldering on such a critical connection. Any suggestions on an alternative connector? Was thinking of a yellow butt-join crimp connector - I think they're rated at 30A plus?

Off to the chandlers tomorrow to replace my fire extinguisher!